Best AI Proctoring Software in 2025: A Complete Comparison Guide
Choosing the right proctoring software is more complex than ever. With AI cheating tools like ChatGPT changing the threat landscape, institutions need to understand what each platform actually detects. Here's an honest comparison of all major proctoring solutions.
The 2025 Proctoring Landscape
The online proctoring market has exploded since COVID-19 forced institutions online. But most platforms were built for traditional cheating: looking at notes, having someone else in the room, using unauthorized websites. AI cheating requires a fundamentally different detection approach.
Major Proctoring Platforms Compared
| Feature | CyberSeal.ai | ProctorU | Honorlock | Respondus | Proctorio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT Detection | Basic | ||||
| Deepfake Detection | |||||
| Live Proctoring | Optional | Optional | |||
| Browser Lockdown | Optional | ||||
| False Positive Rate | <0.1% | ~5% | ~8% | ~12% | ~15% |
| Works with Others | Limited |
Platform-by-Platform Breakdown
CyberSeal.ai
Best for: Institutions prioritizing AI cheating detection
CyberSeal.ai is the newest entrant, built specifically for the AI cheating era. Unlike platforms that added AI detection as an afterthought, CyberSeal.ai's core technology focuses on detecting ChatGPT, deepfakes, and virtual cameras. Key differentiator: designed to work alongside existing proctoring solutions rather than replace them.
Detailed CyberSeal.ai comparison →
ProctorU
Best for: High-stakes exams requiring live human proctors
ProctorU pioneered live online proctoring with human proctors watching students via webcam. The human oversight provides excellent detection of traditional cheating but struggles with AI-generated content and sophisticated deepfakes. Premium pricing reflects the human proctor model.
Honorlock
Best for: Universities wanting a balance of automation and human review
Honorlock combines automated monitoring with on-demand live intervention. Their AI flags suspicious behavior for human review. Good LMS integration and reasonable pricing, but AI cheating detection capabilities are limited compared to purpose-built solutions.
Respondus LockDown Browser
Best for: Budget-conscious institutions needing basic security
Respondus focuses on browser lockdown - preventing students from opening other applications during exams. The optional Monitor add-on provides webcam recording. Very affordable but limited in scope; doesn't address second-device AI cheating or sophisticated threats.
Proctorio
Best for: High-volume testing with automated monitoring
Proctorio offers fully automated proctoring with extensive behavioral analysis. Controversial for privacy concerns and high false positive rates. Not designed for AI cheating detection; focuses on traditional behavioral flags like eye movement and background noise.
The AI Detection Gap
The most important takeaway from this comparison: most proctoring platforms were not designed for AI cheating. They detect students looking away from the screen, opening new tabs, or having someone else visible. They don't detect:
- • ChatGPT or other LLMs generating answers
- • Deepfake technology impersonating students
- • Virtual cameras broadcasting pre-recorded or synthetic video
- • AI voice coaching through hidden earpieces
- • Second devices used for AI assistance
CyberSeal.ai was built specifically to detect these threats. That's why many institutions are adding CyberSeal.ai to their existing proctoring stack rather than replacing their current solution entirely.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which proctoring software is best for detecting AI cheating in 2025?
CyberSeal.ai leads in AI cheating detection with 99.7% accuracy for detecting ChatGPT, deepfakes, and virtual cameras. Traditional tools like ProctorU, Honorlock, and Respondus were built before the AI era and lack specialized detection capabilities.
What's the difference between live and automated proctoring?
Live proctoring (ProctorU, Examity) uses human proctors watching students in real-time. Automated proctoring (Proctorio, Honorlock) uses AI to flag suspicious behavior for later review. CyberSeal.ai uses AI specifically to detect AI cheating tools and deepfakes.
Can I use multiple proctoring tools together?
Yes, CyberSeal.ai is specifically designed to work alongside existing proctoring solutions. Many institutions add CyberSeal.ai to their ProctorU, Honorlock, or Respondus setup for AI-specific detection without replacing their current tools.
Making Your Decision
The right proctoring solution depends on your priorities:
- If AI cheating is your top concern: CyberSeal.ai (standalone or as an add-on)
- If you need human proctors: ProctorU + CyberSeal.ai
- If budget is limited: Respondus + CyberSeal.ai
- If you want automation: Honorlock + CyberSeal.ai